Reservation
+1 718-384-8669
Visit Us
355 Graham Ave #3708, Brooklyn, NY 11211, United States
Hello dear
Welcome To Tony's Brooklyn Pizza
Tony's Brooklyn Pizza, located at 355 Graham Ave, Brooklyn, NY, stands as a beacon of traditional New York-style pizza. Known for its vibrant atmosphere and beloved by locals, this pizzeria offers a rich variety of pies, including classic Napolitan and Sicilian styles, alongside specialty pizzas like the Baked Chicken Ranch and Grandma Pizza. With a commitment to quality, Tony's is a favorite stop for both quick slices and catering needs. Customers rave about the friendly service, iconic flavors, and delicious cheese pulls, making each visit a memorable experience steeped in Brooklyn culture. Enjoy the cinematic vibes as you savor every bite!
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
2 Liter Soda
Chicken With Vodka Sauce Hot Hero
Americana Pizzette
Sfincione Onion Pizza
About
Tony's Brooklyn Pizza
Welcome to Tony's Brooklyn Pizza, a cherished gem nestled in the heart of Brooklyn at 355 Graham Ave. This eatery has mastered the art of crafting authentic New York-style pizzas that evoke a sense of nostalgia and flavor. From the moment you step inside, the vibrant ambiance and the unmistakable sounds of Brooklyn life envelop you, making you feel right at home. With the warmth of friendly service, you’ll find it hard to leave without a slice — or two!
The menu boasts an impressive selection, starting with classic appetizers that perfectly set the stage for your meal. Indulge in Baked Clams Oreganata for an authentic taste of Italian tradition or savor the crispy delights of their Onion Rings and Garlic Bread. One cannot overlook the Hot Antipasto, a sizzling medley that promises to delight your palate.
Of course, the star of the show is the pizza. Tony's serves various styles, including the delicious Napolitan and the crowd-favorite Sicilian. Patrons rave about the Vodka pizza, renowned for its creamy sauce and gooey cheese that pulls perfectly with every slice. Another highlight is the famous Upside Down and Cowboy slices, to which many return time and again. As Nino Cosoleto-Miller shared, the thick Brooklyn accents of the staff add a delightful authenticity to the experience.
Catering options are also a hit, with families praising Tony's for its reliability and quality. Angelina expressed gratitude for a well-delivered catering meal, complete with all the necessary accompaniments. This attention to detail makes Tony's a stellar choice for any gathering.
But don’t just take my word for it. Loyal customers like Lynda Galasso reminisce about Tony's pizza as a family tradition, underscoring its place as a must-visit destination for both locals and visitors. If you’re in the area, make sure to stop by and experience the heart and soul of Brooklyn pizza culture at Tony's Brooklyn Pizza. With flavors that resonate and a passionate community behind it, it's clear why this establishment remains a beloved institution.
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Service was excellent— love ordering NY pizza from a spot where you hear “see ya later Paulie” from a regular as they leave the shop. The vibes inside are awesome, almost cinematic. I got the Vodka pizza, it was fire, the cheese pull was nice too!! ”
“ We were headed to a different Tonys but this was a pleasant surprise. The service and recommendations from Paul were amazing. The Upside Down and The Cowboy slices were DELICIOUS! Definitely would come back and recommend. Slushy was good too! ”
“ Spectacular old-school New York Pizza! We were on a time crunch headed to a show at Brooklyn Steel, and this place is practically right outside the Graham Ave. L station. So we hopped off the train and scored some pizza. She got a slice of Grandma's, and I got two big Sicilian slices. They were heavenly, as I knew they would be, upon hearing the thick Brooklyn accents of the guys working there and the other customers. Love it. I would make it a point to go back here. ”
“ Excellent! Thank you for preparing my catering meal and delivering it on time. We ordered 1/2 tray meatballs and 1/2 lasagna. It was delivered hot and attractively packaged. Additionally, we bought a quart of Pasta Figoli Soup. Freddy deliverered with a smile and was professional. Serving utensils, plates, and bread were supplied. Great first impression. We highly recommend for your next catering event! ”
“ My family and I have enjoyed Tony's pizza for as long as I can remember. We no longer live in Brooklyn however, whenever we visit, it's our first stop now our kids get to enjoy the BEST pizza in the world! ... ”
“ Best pizza & Pasta Spot. The penne Alla vodka with shrimp is the best. What sets the restaurant apart is the staff. They all make you feel special and always ready to assist. My best Italian spot in Williamsburg. A big shout out to the BROTHERS. See you Soon ”
“ I got a slice of cheese (just came out of the oven) and a slice of the tomato and basil. Both the fresh and reheated slice had a nice crisp chew, the sauce was bright without being acidic and the cheese tasted high quality. The real treat here though are the employees. Super friendly and personable. All around a great lunch stop. ”
“ I have to give five stars I came here a few months ago for two plates of chicken fettuccine and boy did my daughter and I enjoy it I stopped by today for a couple of slices of pizzas and A spinach wrap I’m not pronouncing it correctly. I just saw it and wanted it. It was so good. The atmosphere is always beautiful. The service is always kind. The food is always great. They speak to us as we’re entering the store. I love that my dark skin didn’t matter. I felt welcome here, I love this place ”